The Tax Justice Network Africa (TJNA) and the Tunisian Observatory of Economy (TOE), along with other civil society organizations (CSOs), have been engaged in a high-impact campaign to establish global and continental alliances across Africa. Their goal is to resist the OECD-led global tax reforms and amplify the voices of African and Global South organizations and governments in advocating for a new framework for international tax cooperation under the auspices of the United Nations (UN). This campaign, aiming to promote more equitable global tax policies, seeks to connect local, regional, and global efforts to protect the interests of African countries in tax matters for development and rights financing.
In the drive for reform, Africa has demonstrated exceptional leadership. In May 2022, African Ministers of Finance, Planning, and Economic Development adopted a groundbreaking resolution urging the UN to initiate negotiations for an international convention on tax matters, inclusive of all member states. This initiative gained further traction in November 2022 when the African Group, spearheaded by Nigeria, presented a revised resolution at the UN. This resolution focused on the "Promotion of inclusive and effective international tax cooperation at the United Nations."
On December 30, 2022, the United Nations General Assembly adopted Resolution 77/244, which strongly advocates for the advancement of inclusive and effective cooperation on tax matters. This resolution mandates the UN Secretary-General to compile a comprehensive report through consultations with various stakeholders, underscoring the global commitment to tax justice and equitable international tax cooperation.
These efforts highlight the strategic and coordinated push by African nations and allied organizations to reshape the global tax landscape, ensuring that it is fair and beneficial for all, particularly for developing countries. The campaign reflects a broader movement towards achieving sustainable development goals through robust and inclusive financial frameworks.
Following this directive, the UN Secretary-General engaged in consultations and released a report in September 2023. In Dec 2023, the general assembly adopted Resolution 78/2301 which among other things outlined the subsequent procedural steps. UN member states have implemented the recommended procedural steps, setting up an adhoc committee, convening an organizational session, convening the first substantive session and starting the process of developing the TORs to guide the process of developing the text of the UN Tax Convention. The Bureau of the Ad Hoc intergovernmental committee comprises 4 member states, Egypt, Kenya, Morocco and Ghana, representing Africa
The report from the process of developing the ToRs is due for submission at the next UN General Assembly in September 2024, and the negotiations for the content of the convention are due to start in 2025.
Nevertheless, the battle is not over. Within the UN, the countries of the Global North continue to show that they are unwilling to relinquish their dominant position of rule-makers.
African countries will have to join forces to resist the harmful reforms of the OECD.
African nations face a significant challenge with the recent OECD two-pillar solution designed to address the taxation of multinational companies. The two-pillar solution aims to set international rules for taxing the digital economy (Pillar 1) and establish a global minimum tax rate of 15% (Pillar 2). While these reforms are presented as mechanisms to improve global tax fairness, their implementation poses serious risks to the fiscal sovereignty and economic stability of developing countries.
Pillar 1 on the taxation of the Digital Economy requires countries to forgo unilateral digital services taxes. For many African nations, these taxes are crucial revenue sources necessary to meet public spending and development goals. Relinquishing the ability to tax digital services unilaterally is projected to diminish the fiscal capacity of African governments, undermining their ability to fulfill socio-economic rights and finance public services.
Pillar 2, which introduces an effective Global Minimum Tax rate of 15% is criticized for being too low to benefit developing countries effectively. It may fail to generate substantial revenue and could lead to a revenue shift favoring developed nations. This pillar might exacerbate the global "race to the bottom," where countries competitively lower their tax rates to attract investment, further reducing potential tax revenues in Africa.
Despite the potential adverse effects, several African countries, including South Africa, Zimbabwe, Kenya, Tunisia, Morocco, Egypt, and Mauritania, are in various stages of implementing the OECD rules, such as the domestic minimum top-up tax. This move threatens to solidify a tax regime that may not align with the developmental needs of the continent.
The UN Tax Convention shall pave the way for effective global Tax Cooperation
The UN Tax Convention represents a groundbreaking opportunity to establish a comprehensive and equitable framework for global tax cooperation. This initiative aims to ensure that tax rules are developed and discussed inclusively, without discrimination, and with a focus on safeguarding developing countries' interests and sovereignty.
The UN Tax Convention is poised to redefine the fundamental principles of the international tax system. Its goals include achieving full inclusiveness, fairness, and effectiveness in global tax governance. For Africa, this moment presents a critical opportunity to shape a continent-wide agenda that reflects the interests of all African nations. By rallying support for the African Group's position throughout the UN negotiation process, African stakeholders can significantly influence the outcome.
One of the primaries aims of the new tax cooperation principles is to restore the sovereignty of nations and bolster the political legitimacy of global tax frameworks. Establishing new global tax rules is essential for Domestic Revenue Mobilization (DRM), which is crucial for sustainable development. African leaders have been at the forefront of conceptualizing and implementing these reforms, demonstrating the continent's agency and influence in the international economic order.
Despite the progress made, there are still gaps in advocacy, reflection, and knowledge, particularly in regions like North Africa. To address this, the Tax Justice Network Africa (TJNA) and the Tunisian Observatory of Economy (TOE) are organizing a regional conference in Tunis on June 24-25, 2024. This conference aims to engage civil society organizations (CSOs) in discussions on the UN framework convention and renew a regional action agenda regarding global tax reforms.
The conference will feature a series of presentations, roundtable discussions, and breakout sessions. These activities are designed to foster a deep and collaborative dialogue among participants. The goal is for CSOs to develop regional action plans, a continental advocacy strategy, and a comprehensive outcome document. This document will guide partners in their advocacy efforts towards the successful adoption of the UN framework convention.
By seizing this moment, African nations can lead the way in establishing a just and effective global tax system that supports sustainable development and protects the fiscal sovereignty of developing countries.
Objectives of the conference
-
* Create a Pan-African space to discuss and analyze the challenges and opportunities of international tax reform and explore the potential of the UN Tax Convention as a more democratic and inclusive framework;
-
* Promote the understanding of the process of discussions and development of the UN tax convention and reflect on the critical role of civil society organizations in this endeavor;
-
* Facilitate the growth of regional coalitions to advocate for equitable tax policies, while beginning to plan the next critical steps for stakeholders to advocate for the UN Tax;
-
* Convention and contribute to its ToRs and contents.